Contract Administration

 View Only
Expand all | Collapse all

Construction Management Software - Undue Hardship on Owners and Architects

  • 1.  Construction Management Software - Undue Hardship on Owners and Architects

    Posted 09-02-2025 12:38 PM

    While construction management software (CMS) helps contractors streamline their projects, expecting architectural and engineering (A/E) firms to use a different system for each project creates an unreasonable burden. Therefore, it is unreasonable to expect architects and engineers to participate in the process because of the logistical, financial, and professional challenges that will be imposed on them.

    Forcing an A/E firm to use an unfamiliar, contractor-specific system also jeopardizes their professional obligation to meet the standard of care. When design professionals lose control over documentation and communication-including RFIs and submittals-it can expose them to significant liability if information is lost, delayed, or mishandled by a system they are not responsible for maintaining.

    Until the industry widely adopts a standardized platform-agnostic file-sharing system that does not impose a significant burden on any single party, we include the following articles in our bidding and contract documents:

    00 2113 - Instructions to Bidders

    The Owner and the Architect will not be required to use any Bidder's web-based or other construction management software for any communication, including but not limited to responses to Requests for Information (RFIs).

    RFIs requiring the use of a Bidder's construction management software will not be acknowledged or responded to by the Owner or Architect.

    01 3000 – Administrative Requirements

    The Owner and the Architect will not be required to use the Contractor's web-based or other construction management software for any communication, including but not limited to responses to Requests for Information (RFIs) and submittals.

    I am interested to know if other design professionals share these concerns and if similar articles are being included in their bidding and construction documents.



    ------------------------------
    Charles Green BS, MA, FCSI, CCS©, CCCA©
    Wilson & Company
    crgreen@wilsonco.com
    ------------------------------


  • 2.  RE: Construction Management Software - Undue Hardship on Owners and Architects

    Posted 09-03-2025 08:21 AM

    I am the Architectural Administrator for our firm.  As of right now, we have 15 projects in the works with 13 of them using a Construction Project Management Software.  I have found that the learning curve is normally minimal as most are based on the same principles, like Microsoft Word and Google Word Processing.  A little difference in how things are said may be there but for the most part it is the same.  I have had no issues with using their software and as a matter of fact I find it much easier to send back and forth.  I do require, however, that all Submittals, RFIs, etc flow through me and not go directly to the Engineers and Consultants.  Other than that I have no real issues.  I am or have used ProCore, Autodesk, Red Team Go, and a couple of others in the early days.  I find they are, for the most part, so similar that there is little to no issues keeping up.  



    ------------------------------
    Billy Mathis FCSI, CDT®
    Administrative Assistant for Architecture
    Taggart Architects
    North Little Rock AR
    501-951-1061
    ------------------------------



  • 3.  RE: Construction Management Software - Undue Hardship on Owners and Architects

    Posted 09-03-2025 09:25 AM

    Billy - setting the learning curve for the various systems aside for a moment, assuming you archive documents in your own computer system as well, what benefit does the extra, unpaid effort provide? 

    Why not streamline the workflow by simply requiring submittals and documents to be provided in PDF format, provide a response, and archive the documents in your own system? 



    ------------------------------
    Charles Green BS, MA, FCSI, CCS©, CCCA©
    Wilson & Company
    crgreen@wilsonco.com
    ------------------------------



  • 4.  RE: Construction Management Software - Undue Hardship on Owners and Architects

    Posted 09-03-2025 10:52 AM

    Very good question.  If you use the old school, email system - you first receive the submittal (either email or download from a transfer program like Sharefile) and place it in your filing system for the Project; then you prepare the transmittal to the reviewer if outside the office or refer to the reviewer inside the office.  You then get the response, formulate a transmittal and send via email or transfer system to the Contractor.  

    If you use the construction management program, you get the notice the submittal or RFI is ready and you download it from the program and place it in your filing system for the Project; then you prepare the transmittal to the reviewer if outside the office or refer to the reviewer inside the office.  You then get the response, formulate a transmittal and send via the program back to the contractor.

    From my viewpoint, the system is basically untouched other that having to learn how to download from and upload to the system.  That is how it work for us.  Your experience may be totally different based on your system and how you do things.

       



    ------------------------------
    Billy Mathis FCSI, CDT®
    Administrative Assistant for Architecture
    Taggart Architects
    North Little Rock AR
    501-951-1061
    ------------------------------



  • 5.  RE: Construction Management Software - Undue Hardship on Owners and Architects

    Posted 09-03-2025 06:01 PM

    Our RFI and submittal workflow, without CMS, is as follows:
    1. Document (RFI/ submittal) received from contractor in PDF format via email and entered into the appropriate log by our gatekeeper (admin staff); the email address is a group email that includes stakeholders from each discipline 
    2. Document assigned to the appropriate design professional by the gatekeeper, and response time monitored by the gatekeeper
    3. Response provided to gatekeeper
    4. Log updated and returned to the contractor by the gatekeeper

    Weaving CMS into the workflow adds more steps to the process



    ------------------------------
    Charles Green BS, MA, FCSI, CCS©, CCCA©
    Wilson & Company
    crgreen@wilsonco.com
    ------------------------------



  • 6.  RE: Construction Management Software - Undue Hardship on Owners and Architects

    Posted 09-03-2025 10:14 AM
    Edited by Daniel Gonzales, CSI, CCCA®, CDT® 09-03-2025 10:14 AM

    It seems like every project uses a different software platform, many large GC's even have developed their own platforms in-house.  We have one large institutional client (an international airport) that requires all projects use the client's own platform. I'm with Billy, the learning curve to pick these up is generally quick.  We manage liability by maintaining our own copies of all submittals/RFIs and logs (showing dates received / returned) on our own server.  And of course I never let our engineers use the platform, all correspondence flows thru me so I'm the only person downloading/uploading items to the platform. 

    -------------------------------------------



  • 7.  RE: Construction Management Software - Undue Hardship on Owners and Architects

    Posted 09-04-2025 08:31 AM

    Charles, 

    Our flow is similar to yours.  In our system I am the gatekeeper and just like Daniel, everything flows through me to the Reviewers and back and I upload.  I too keep my own records and copies of all.  If you analyze the two systems (Yours and Mine) the only real difference is in the receipt and transmission back.   Where you get attachments and downloads through email, I get emails to access the system and download the communication.  When complete, I then upload to the system where you email it back.  I will agree with you in that when I started, I didn't like the systems, however, now that I am using them regularly, I don't see an issue.  I also still have a couple of projects where we work "Old School" but I have a feeling these systems are here to stay.  My one concern would be to integrate one system or platform for use by everyone.  That would take out the learning curve.



    ------------------------------
    Billy Mathis FCSI, CDT®
    Administrative Assistant for Architecture
    Taggart Architects
    North Little Rock AR
    501-951-1061
    ------------------------------



  • 8.  RE: Construction Management Software - Undue Hardship on Owners and Architects

    Posted 09-04-2025 09:35 AM

    Billy - responding to submittals and RFIs without having to use the contractor's Construction Management System (CMS) is more profitable for Architects because it requires less effort to reply to an email than navigating through a CMS website, some of which are less intuitive than others. Multiply that effort for a single response, times hundreds of submittals and RFIs during the project life cycle, times the number of projects a firm works on during the fiscal year, and the result is more unpaid manhours than we want to acknowledge. The profitability gap widens even further when you consider the learning curve and time investment required to train staff on multiple, different CMS platforms.



    ------------------------------
    Charles Green BS, MA, FCSI, CCS©, CCCA©
    Wilson & Company
    crgreen@wilsonco.com
    ------------------------------



  • 9.  RE: Construction Management Software - Undue Hardship on Owners and Architects

    Posted 09-04-2025 09:46 AM

    I respect what you are saying and I can see your point.  I honestly thing we will just need to agree to disagree on this topic.  I feel that neither of us will fully switch sides on the issue and I respect people in these communities to make their own decisions based on the information presented.  Thank you for bringing this topic to the Community.  I think people will learn from this discussion. 



    ------------------------------
    Billy Mathis FCSI, CDT®
    Administrative Assistant for Architecture
    Taggart Architects
    North Little Rock AR
    501-951-1061
    ------------------------------